Landmark court case in London clarifies when capital gains tax is applied


A London property owner who made a big profit on a flat he was unable to reside in has won a landmark appeal against paying a hefty capital gains tax bill.

The issue of exactly when capital gains tax (CGT) should be paid has been clarified in a recent court case, which set out that the bill can only be applied after property completion, regardless of exchange.

In the case, the owner of a London apartment wasn’t able to live in their property for four years as construction was delayed because of the 2008 financial crisis. In 2006, the buyer had put down a deposit and exchanged contracts for the property before construction started on it.

He was unable to live in the flat until 5 January 2010, meaning the purchase wasn’t completed until then and it was the earliest point he could legally occupy the flat. The prolonged investment led the buyer to make a sizeable profit after selling the flat two years later.

Property completion

HMRC charged the buyer capital gains tax for the profit made since 2006, claiming the profit is calculated from when a contract is made. However, since the buyer did not legally own the property between 2006 to 2010, he said he should not be charged for the gains made during that time period.

The First Tier Tribunal agreed that profit on a gain can’t be taxed until after completion, cancelling the initial capital gains tax amount, but the Upper Tax Tribunal sided with HMRC. After the court battle with HMRC, the owner’s appeal was upheld by the England and Wales Court of Appeal.

This court case decision was analysed in a recent article in Today’s Conveyancer. The case clarifies when capital gains tax is applied on a property. Since the buyer didn’t have the legal right to occupy the flat until 2010, the period of ownership could not begin until he was granted this permission.

Changes to capital gains tax

As a landlord or investor, it’s important to understand the regulations behind capital gains tax. Up to half a million landlords could even be impacted by new rules for capital gains tax, which is likely to increase costs when landlords sell their former homes.

Currently, landlords who previously lived in a property but then rented it out can claim capital gains tax relief on the property for up to 18 months after they moved out. However, starting in April 2020, this relief will only be for nine months.

This rule change means holding onto a property after moving out of it with an aim to benefit from rising property prices later is likely to be less attractive to some landlords. Tax changes are pushing many landlords and investors to change their property investment plans.

In order to take advantage of favourable tax rates, more landlords than ever are purchasing properties through limited companies. It’s best for landlords and investors to seek professional advice on ways to minimise the negative effects of new regulations, especially involving capital gains tax.

Highgrove Mews

High Net Yield Freehold Houses

  • Commutable to London (27 mins to central Paddington station)
  • Rental demand extremely strong with large industry presence in Reading
  • Freehold with 4% net yield

£284,955 - £457,000

St Petersgate – Stockport Manchester

New Launch - Stockport Manchester, apartments from £160,000

  • Discounted launch prices from £160,000
  • Excellent transport links with 3 trains per hour to London Euston and only 9 mins journey to Manchester Piccadilly
  • Experienced development team

Assured Rent Housing Association Leases

Assured Rent Housing Association Leases

  • Assured rent & no rental voids
  • Tenant damage cover & newly refurbished inline with requirements of a corporate sitting tenant
  • Free property and lettings management

From £62,000

Emerging Birmingham Commuter Town With Properties From Just £104,000

The emerging Birmingham commuter town where properties are selling in an average of just 24 days

  • A collection of 62 two bedroom apartments and 28 one bedroom apartments.
  • DE14 is one of the fastest selling postcodes in the West Midlands.
  • 23 minute train journey into Birmingham New Street Station.

Properties from £104,000

Mill, Stockport

The Northwest's emerging property hotspot

  • Discounted off-plan 2-bed prices from £162,000
  • Completion date - Q4 2021
  • Rental yields - 6% plus

Discounted off-plan 2-bed prices from £162,000

South Central – Birmingham City Centre Apartments

Highly anticipated 28 storey launch in Birmingham City Centre with an impressive roof garden and communal facilities.

  • 154 units across 28 storeys
  • Residential multi-media community room, gym, roof garden and sky cinema
  • Excellent future connectivity via the metro system to other key transport hubs and locations around the city

from £205,800


Talk to us

Speak to our UK property experts today: 

+44 (0) 333 123 0320

Open from 9am-6pm GMT

+852 9865 4446

Open from 9am-6pm HKT

Stamp Duty Calculator


Unlock members only investment opportunities and full development details. Join now – it’s free, quick and easy.


Not a member? Sign up for free

Court case

Landmark court case in London clarifies when capital gains tax is applied


By submitting your details via this online form you agree to be contacted via email/phone/SMS by Direct Marketplace Ltd t/a BuyAssociation in relation to property investment and property developments . We do not share your personal details with third parties.  To view our full Privacy Policy click here.